Skip to main content

Health Care (Tax)

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's Bill Toland wrote a pretty good history of America's health care system and how it evolved throughout the 20th Century and though he left out some nuggets who the hell really cares. The point is, it's been a rolling clusterfuck pretty much from day one and the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) doesn't change that reality in the slightest. Everyone calls it Obamacare as though, somehow, Obama was the designer and implementer (if you could even call it implemented, which you can't) of this monstrosity - but a better name for the ACA is Obamatax because taxing is what the bill/law has always been about. With taxes comes pain and slow economic growth but we'll all get through it and at the end of the day... we'll still have a health care crisis in America! Because health insurance does not equate to health care - making the world better for insurance companies is a noble goal and bilking dollars for the Federal treasury from an oblivious public is Washington DC's raison d'être but neither of those things are health care.

The fact of the matter is that politicians from both parties have been trying to foist the cost of health insurance off the backs of business and onto the backs of "their' citizens for decades. The reason is simple, if you're a multinational corporation employing a person in Germany that employee doesn't cost you any direct payments for health insurance, but if you do business in the USA that employee is EXPENSIVE. For many years it was worth picking up the extra cost per employee because the American workers were 1. worth the money and 2. corporations needed to do business in the US - it was a very important marketplace. #1 is no longer true and #2 is not as true as it used to be. That's not even taking into account health pension costs for retired employees. Once the financial collapse of 2008 occurred this private health insurance cost problem combined with the fact that the US treasury needed money - A LOT of money fast (more than could be raised in a marginal tax increase) made the passage of a comprehensive national healthcare law with associated (and unassociated) taxes inevitable.

The best health care plan, not surprisingly, was Nixon's comprehensive health insurance plan proposed to Congress in 1974. Of course, Nixon's plan did not raise taxes, kept the relationship between patient and doctor paramount, maintained the employer contribution and generally supported the free enterprise system while ensuring universal coverage. The Democrats wanted single payer or nothing so Ted Kennedy killed Nixon's plan in the Senate and another 20 years passed.

Fast forward to 1993 and the twofer the country got when they took on the Clampetts. HRC ran this nationalized health care task force right into a Democrat controlled congress - anybody remember that? Paul Starr does and if you can bear to read even the positive partisan recounting of events you'll understand why Democrats should just stay away from comprehensive anything and stick to picayune legislation and naming buildings after themselves. Bob Dole killed Hilerycare with only 43 GOP Senators on his team. How? It's easy, but I'll get to that in a minute...

That brings us to the Obama era and Obamacare which has been one frustrating mess from day 0 when the light worker flubbed his oath of office or was bamboozled by Justice Roberts or whatever. Yes, extraordinary actions (bribes) and parliamentary tricks where used to pass Obamacare before midnight on Christmas Eve 2009 and it's been a cat fight ever since - the entire history of which is too much to regurgitate but in light of today's Supreme Court ruling on King v Burwell (which basically just opens the spigots on Federal spending) a few points should be made:
  • If Bob Dole could kill Hilarycare then you KNOW Mitch McConnell could have killed Obamacare. Don't give me the every GOP Senator voted against it crap - who cares? The Republicans were in the same rooms with the Dems, having lunch together, writing legislation together, on the cocktail circuit together, flying off on corporate funded boondoggles together and if they had wanted it killed - I mean really wanted it killed - the Senate GOP old bulls would have shot it in the head. Most people don't realize it but a single Senator can kill almost any piece of legislation just by his lonesome and so the fact that it passed at all, even with all the for show consternation by the conservative Senators, means that both Parties were OK with it.
  • All the Repeal Votes coming from the House after the 2010 elections were for show.
  • In 2012 SCOTUS upheld the "individual mandate" (the very phrase is about as UN-American as they come) and let me paraphrase the reasoning as best as I can: The IM is unconstitutional for no free citizen can be compelled to buy a good or service from a private company without consent, but the Government is simply lying to you when they say they are requiring you to buy insurance - what they're really doing is Taxing you. The Federal Government DOES have the power to tax as much as it wants so consider yourself taxed America - GET IT!
  • No! America didn't get it, so we come to my favorite piece of Obamacare theater - the October 2013 fight over the continuing resolution to keep the Federal Government open for business. How Ted Cruz and Mike Lee convinced the House to give them a bill that funded all of government except the ACA will be a great story (if it ever gets told) but once these maverick freshman Senators had the pliers in hand they quickly clamped them to the testicles of the Republican Bulls who always bellow about how bad Obamacare is but, in truth, are behind it all the way. Screams of agony from the GOP cloak room can still be heard echoing down the Washington DC mall as Cruz FORCED them to vote on cloture and be counted.
Oh yeah, I'm going to name the yellow-bellied scum right now:

Lamar Alexander (R-TN)
Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)
John Barrasso (R-WY)
Roy Blunt (R-MO)
John Boozman (R-AR)
Richard Burr (R-NC)
Saxby Chambliss (R-GA)
Jeff Chiesa (R-NJ)
Daniel Coats (R-IN)
Tom Coburn (R-OK)
Thad Cochran (R-MS)
Susan Collins (R-ME)
Bob Corker (R-TN)
John Cornyn (R-TX)
Lindsey Graham (R-SC)
John Hoeven (R-ND)
Johnny Isakson (R-GA)
Mike Johanns (R-NE)
Mark Kirk (R-IL)
Ron Johnson (R-WI)
John McCain (R-AZ)
Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
Lisa Murkowski (R-AK)
John Thune (R-SD)
Roger Wicker (R-MS)

If the GOP had refused to vote on cloture and kept debate open for a few weeks until the Obamacare web site launched (or crashed to be more accurate) then Obamacare would have been toast. But Mitch McConnell saved Obama's ass (again) and the rest is a story about how horrible Ted Cruz is and how angry members of his own party are at him and blah, blah, blah.
Today SCOTUS did it again with their customary flair for unconventional jurisprudence and told America one last time, loud and clear - Obamacare stays! All the conservatives can do is pull quotes from Scalia’s Scathing Dissent (like they always do) and try to be satisfied that even though they got nothing of substance at least they have well worded indignation to mull over at bedtime.


Popular posts from this blog

The Real Story with Gretchen Carlson

She was "sexy", but "too much hard work." I'm a regular Fox & Friends viewer (mostly in protest of the other insipid morning programs like Today and Good Morning America) so over the years I've gotten to know Gretchen Carlson pretty well. Stuck between Steve and Brian she always seemed a prudish scold with an irritating, self-righteous demeanor that I simply put up with because I figured some people in the Fox audience actually liked her persona. It was obvious that Steve and Brian did not, but they were stuck with her like so many talking heads and had to make the best of it - which they did. Besides, she was no worse than any of the other women on morning show TV - I mean, you're only going to find a certain kind of person to do this kind of work and that kind of person is the Gretchen Carlson kind. Then, one day, she was gone and replaced by Elisabeth Hasselbeck and the F&F ratings began to climb, and climb and climb - in two months view

The 4th Estate "does not know"

Last night Jim Acosta sat down for an interview with Larry Sabato at a national symposium series presented by the University of Virginia’s Center for Politics titled “Democracy in Perilous Times.” The evening’s topic was “ The Fourth Estate: Enemy of the People? ” and the crowd was warmly receptive of Acosta’s message which, boiled down to its essence, is that Donald Trump is a liar and he’s making life dangerous for reporters. Sabato introduced Acosta to the audience as Enemy #1 which drew mirthful laughter from the auditorium and then presented a short video montage of President Trump and his deplorable rubes insulting the reporter on many occasions over the past two years. This was all a set up for his first question which was, “how do you do your Job?” Acosta said the he accomplishes his duties by maintaining focus, reporting the story and telling the truth but acknowledged that it is difficult when the White House erodes the peoples faith in the press by bullying reporters. Whe

A Apolitical Blues

Well my telephone was ringing, and they told me it was chairman Mao. You got to tell him anything 'cause I just don't want to talk to him now. According to the brilliant troubadour Lowell George the Apolitical Blues are " the meanest blues of all" and who am I to disagree with this soul man now after all these years of living by his maxim.  I first heard the song bursting from the 1972 vinyl of Little Feat's Alt-Rock-Country masterpiece "Sailin' Shoes" in the second story bedroom of my friend John's older brother Edie who, being about 3 years our senior, was instructing us on the importance of good music. This was circa 1975 and a formative time for my musical taste and overall aesthetic which, for better or worse, infuses every aspect of my existence including the KOTCB blog so a debt is owed this unforgettable "older brother" now that  he has shuffled off this mortal coil  and left us with smoky memories. A born rebel with the heart o